The Office of the Commissioner of Baseball
Allan H. (Bud) Selig, Commissioner
245 Park Avenue, 31st Floor
New York, NY 10167
(212) 931-3800
Dear Mr. Commissioner:
Tomorrow night at Kauffman Stadium, Royals play-by-play announcer Denny Matthews will be recognized as this year’s Ford C. Frick hall-of-fame inductee. In addition to the George Brett Pine Tar Anniversary t-shirts, the Royals will be giving out pins to honor Matthews and his continued excellence that began with the Royals’ inception in 1969. When I was a kid, you almost assumed that everyone always played for/worked for the same club their entire career; it was always weird to see guys acquired via trade or free agency. Brett and Matthews both fall into the no-longer-existent category of being employed by the same club for your entire career.
There’s another guy that’s touched baseball in a great way, and played 75% of his career with the same club. His name’s Pete Rose. Of his 24 years on the majors, Rose logged 18 of those with the Cincinnati Reds. The other six, of course, came in the form of five with the Philadelphia Phillies and one with the Montreal Expos. That’s pretty impressive in my book, and Rose is probably a hero in the minds of most Phillies and Reds fans. He should be recognized as a hero to the game, and have a spot in baseball’s hall of fame.
Word on the Internets and in the newspapers today is that you will not be attending any games throughout the duration of the current San Francisco Giants’ homes stand. I’m curious how you will be utilizing your official time, then, and am optimistic that some of that time will be spent re-assessing the Rose situation as his place in Cooperstown is imperative. With all due respect to the ongoings in the commissioner’s office, I would like to suggest that the removal of Pete Rose’s ban from baseball be added to the pile of things to be done.
The Office of the Commissioner of Baseball
Allan H. (Bud) Selig, Commissioner
245 Park Avenue, 31st Floor
New York, NY 10167
(212) 931-3800
Dear Mr. Commissioner:
July is almost behind us, division races are tightening up, and wildcard spots are becoming the focus of daily baseball conversation. In the city in which your office operates, the hometown Yankees are closing in on the Boston Red Sox; here in the American League Central, the Cleveland Indians and Detroit Tigers seem to swap first and second places as often as most hurlers vary between strikes and balls. The Royals are on pace to have their second consecutive winning month for the first time in ages. Speaking of non-first place teams, the Yankees will be in town for a four-game series, the second game of which will be the 24th anniversary of the esteemed Pine Tar Incident (note: letter from last Friday on this topic).
I was troubled this week when I discovered that the court case mentioned in The Kansas City Star article had a side note to it: It was the first ruling in which YouTube.com was involved/mentioned. Apparently, it was determined that Major League Baseball owns the rights to the video footage of the Pine Tar Incident, YouTube was contacted and asked to remove the footage (as per some sort of copyright violation), and they acted accordingly. Thus, I found it incredibly disappointing that Pine Tar footage was no longer accessible.
Not as disappointing as Pete Rose not being in the Hall of Fame, but, hey – apples and oranges. Everything is ripe for the picking. Barry Bonds breaks Hank Aaron’s record; the Yankees may not win the AL East for the first time in nine consecutive seasons; the Colorado Rockies are playing well, as are the Royals; your Brewers are on a tear; Chicago Cubs fans are beside themselves; Pine Tar Anniversary celebration will be commemorated by fancy George Brett powder blue t-shirts. Why not throw one more good ingredient into the big batch of awesome? Why not release the demons associated with Pete Rose’s past? Why not lift the ban on Charlie Hustle? It could be the ultimate recipe for continued excellence in the bigs.
The Office of the Commissioner of Baseball
Allan H. (Bud) Selig, Commissioner
245 Park Avenue, 31st Floor
New York, NY 10167
(212) 931-3800
Dear Mr. Commissioner:
Though we’re still 11 days away from the 24th anniversary of the George Brett pine tar incident (note: hint as to what I’ll be writing about that day), but there was an interesting article in today’s Business Section of The Kansas City Star. Dan Margolies wrote about a legal dispute between one Leo Stoller and Brett Brothers Sports International, Inc. What the dispute was regarding is of little interest. Early in the article, however, Margolies offers this fine paragraph:
"Fans all remember that Brett’s dramatic ninth-inning home run against the
Yankees, putting the Royals ahead, was nullified by home plate umpire Tim
McClelland after he determined that the pine tar on Brett’s bat exceeded 18
inches in length. What fans may not remember is that American League president
Lee MacPhail subsequently overruled McClelland, and the Royals wound up winning
the game."
I like that term: nullified. I also like the brass it takes for a president to overrule what one of his colleagues has done. A. Bartlett Giamatti and Fay Vincent, Jr. are both respectable men, I’m sure. I continue to insist that no disrespect would be done to either individual were the ban on Pete Rose to be lifted. Margolies closes his piece with the phrase, “it’s a good thing that our legal system, like baseball, has appellate review.”If baseball has appellate review, let’s review that August day in 1989 and re-consider the implications of Giamatti’s decision 18 years ago. Rose belongs in the Hall. I honorably request that you take the first step in putting him there. Tim McClelland made a mistake in that call, yet he continued an amazing career calling games. Why can’t the same oversight be attributed to Rose’s case? I suspect that it can, and hope that we will one day see eye to eye on this matter.